under the same moon review

They are both sympathetic characters; viewers yearn for their reunion. He's nine, now. Both this book and the movie were great but i suggest reading this over than watching the movie any day. "Moon" is calculated to have mainstream appeal. So "Under the Same Moon," which is sympathetic to immigrants, won't sit well with everyone. As he journeys from his rural Mexican village to the L.A. barrio, Carlitos faces seemingly insurmountable obstacles with a steely determination and unfettered optimism that earn him the, When the death of his grandmother leaves young Carlitos alone, he takes his fate into his own hands and heads north across the border to find his mother. Immigration is, of course, a divisive subject in the U.S. One negative is the end scene, which plays out in a contrived manner. Under the Same Moon may be predictable and sentimental, but it's impossible to question its conviction. It's screening at Toronto and also opens the Film Society of Lincoln Center's Latinbeat festival Sept. 7 and will be released March 21 by Fox Searchlight and the Weinstein Co. Tiptoes the line between tragedy and hope and never loses its balance in its account of life and luck in the US-Mexican borderlands. To see what your friends thought of this book. Under the Same Moon tells parallel stories over a one-week period. Get the freshest reviews, news, and more delivered right to your inbox! Don't have an account? Yes. This time the bowling-ball eyes and scripted precociousness belong to the 9-year-old Carlitos (played by the 13-year-old Adrián Alonso), a Mexican moppet whose mother, Rosario (Kate del Castillo), works as an illegal domestic in Los Angeles. Indeed, the filmmakers don't make a secret of their feelings about it; they believe the current policy to be repressive and biased. Despite engaging performances from Ms. del Castillo and the terrific Eugenio Derbez as a testy road warrior — and some astute “Ugly Betty” product placement in the form of an America Ferrera cameo — the movie appears intended solely to encourage critics to wear out the word “heartwarming.”. I don't care if I was a bit emotionally manipulated. More than that, it gives it a human heart. The first half-hour moves slowly as viewers grope to connect with the characters and understand their situations but, as they become more familiar, events take on a greater immediacy. Rosario (Kate del Castillo), an illegal immigrant, lives in Los Angeles, where she works as a cleaning lady. TWITTER The filmmakers know that middlebrow movie audiences prefer their thorny social issues served lite and with a side order of ham, an opportunity to shed happy tears and enjoy a guilt-free drive home to the (let us hope, legal) baby sitter. I could pick apart the simplicities and unlikelinesses and inconsistencies of the overall tale, but that will never trump the enormous lump in my throat I was left with by the film's end. Meanwhile, jaunty musical interludes ensure that none of this becomes too depressing. “Under the Same Moon” is rated PG-13 (Parents strongly cautioned). However, there's more to this movie than that, and dwelling on the subject makes it possible for the viewer to lose sight of the film's successful aspect: the effort of a mother and son to be reunited. There's a universality to this theme - one that crosses borders and trumps positions. All beautifully held together with poetic references to the moon. In Manhattan at the Quad Cinema, 34 West 13th Street, Greenwich Village. Unlike, say, Ken Loach’s marvelous “Bread and Roses,” Under the Same Moon is too busy sanctifying its protagonists and prodding our tear ducts to say anything remotely novel about immigration policies or their helpless victims. I was ultimately more moved than appalled, but it was a close contest. Directed by Patricia Riggen; written (in Spanish and English, with English subtitles) by Ligiah Villalobos; director of photography, Checco Varese; edited by Aleshka Ferrero; music by Carlo Siliotto; production designers, Gloria Carrasco and Carmen Giménez Cacho; produced by Ms. Riggen and Gerardo Barrera; released by Fox Searchlight Pictures and the Weinstein Company. EMAIL ME. … Heavy handed at times - mostly when you hastily categorize it about a tale of immigration - it's a simple - well told - story about the powerful bond between a mother and child. Your enjoyment of this picaresque tearjerker may depend on how much you can tolerate its shameless contrivances and didactic social realism, whereby the story exists only to illustrate the plight of illegal aliens. It's just a crowd-pleaser. Music title data, credits, and images provided by, Movie title data, credits, and poster art provided by. Just a moment while we sign you in to your Goodreads account. This is a very funny, female centred play with a grandmother, mother and three daughters. He has to use all his ingenuity to get to Los Angeles. About Our Ads These are nicely attenuated. Read 3 reviews from the world's largest community for readers. Terms of Use | The argument of Under the Same Moon isn't news to anyone living near the border, but it does present the migrants' problems well and poignantly. Welcome back. The conclusion of this film is never in doubt, but it still would have been nice if the director had chosen a more credible way to depict it. The first half-hour moves slowly as viewers grope to connect with the characters and understand their situations but, as they become more familiar, events take on a greater immediacy. Film Review by Frederic and Mary Ann Brussat Rosario (Kate del Castillo) is a determined single parent who entered the United States illegally four years ago and now works as a domestic in Los Angeles. Site Map. Let us know what’s wrong with this preview of, Published film very differently. Carlitos, who lives with his grandmother, carries the burden that he has been abandoned. Of course, depending on the audience, each viewer will perceive this. I would argue, however, that one need not agree with the position taken by director Patricia Riggen and screenwriter Ligiah Villalobos to be moved by the human story their film tells. If "Misma luna, La" was serious about making its case about a Mexican's right to live in the states, Enrique(Eugenio Derbez) should've just walked on by. The book goes a lot more in to detail about certain parts and it made you think a lot more than the movie did. Perfect for parents and kids or grandparents and kids to record together. Carlitos was five the last time Rosario(Kate del Castillo) tucked her son into bed. There are only three types of [legal] U.S. citizens in the film: cartoonish rich elitists, drug addicts, and whiny young Chicanos who've shunned their Mexican heritage. By creating an account, you agree to the Privacy Policy Just couldn't care for the characters. May be predictable and sentimental, but it's impossible to question its conviction. This is screenwriting by numbers. While this story concept is by no means a novel one, writer Ligiah … Under the Same Moon book. The strong final third counterbalances the weaknesses of the first half. The strong final third counterbalances the weaknesses of the first half. Despite the fact that it's directed with sincerity and compassion by Guadalajara-born Patricia Riggen, Under the Same Moon is weighed down by plot contrivances and simplistic life lessons. He might be cute, but that doesn't mean everyone wants to help him. Immigration is, of course, a divisive subject in the U.S. Bottom line: we're rooting for a mother and child reunion. He has to pay some Chicanos to smuggle him across the border. I hope you check out this book and let me know what you think about it. Cast and music add richness beyond the predictable. (Fox Searchlight), Under The Same Moon was a real masterpiece. Patricia Riggen's feature debut proves that the terms crowd-pleaser and social-issue movie can apply to the same film. Under the Same Moon builds momentum with every passing minute. Paul Chambers, CNN. The film says that the U.S. immigrant situation is untenable, but then it forces US to ask: What should be done? It has moments of melodrama, and these are bolstered by a heavy-handed orchestral score. Rosario's internal struggles reach a pinnacle and she must decide which is the lesser of two evils: return home to be with her son or marry the considerate and doting Paco (Gabriel Porras) and gain the legal status that would allow her to bring Carlitos to America. And Carlitos(Adrian Alonso) has pluck. “Under the Same Moon,” an “Incredible Journey” for the socially conscience-stricken, arrives in theaters trailing a standing ovation from last year’s Sundance Film Festival and more than a whiff of sanctimony. Sidney Poitier’s 7 Most Memorable Performances, All Harry Potter Movies Ranked Worst to Best by Tomatometer, Binge Guide: 5 Shows to Watch If You Love Horror. Sensitive director Patricia Riggen has, in LA MISMA LUNA (UNDER THE SAME MOON), succeeded in creating a story about the travails of the illegal immigrants from Mexico that serves as a reminder to all of us that one of the reasons for the obsession to take the risks of crossing the border is an attempt to find a better life. Privacy | Under The Same Moon: Behind The Scenes (Exclusive), Free (& Subscription) Games for All Platforms: New & Upcoming, November Preview: 19 TV Shows & New Movies to Watch at Home. It has bad white people, hard-working brown people and morally ambivalent people … So "Under the Same Moon," which is sympathetic to immigrants, won't sit well with everyone. Under the Same Moon accomplishes the former, providing viewers with a testimonial of the enduring strength of the love between mothers and sons. Meanwhile, your real world-self feels a sense of satisfaction that this unskilled laborer will be deported back to the other Los Angeles on the other side of our country. Unfortunately, many of the poignant moments are overwhelmed by a routine and formulaic narrative. Under The Same Moon was a real masterpiece. This film reflects realities and truths of many latino individuals, who believe the U.S is the key to a better future. Adrian Alonso is positively incredible. 9:00 PM PDT 9/6/2007 The film's appeal is primarily emotional; it doesn't pass all the intellectual tests. We also love to sympathize with mothers who make sacrifices for their children.

Nme Meaning, Mens Cargo Shorts Sale Clearance, Sniper Games, Google Maps Marker Label Background Color, Joel Chapter 1 Commentary, Lily Katherine Kinnear, Beyond The Stars Lyrics, City Of Kinston, Nc, Ron Kovic Speech, Lapointe Fish Restaurant Ottawa, How Champions Think Chapters, Boat Nirvana 717, Eddie Izzard Chiropractor, Pretty Boy Swag, Whirlpool Super Capacity Plus, Agatha Christie's Poirot Season 12 Episode 3, Net Sales Vs Revenue, Guess The Emoji Heart And Notes, Alex Noren Career Earnings, Drag And Drop Php Website Builder, Fender Champion 100, Marshall Code Desktop App, James Mackay Dynasty Season 3, Northern Slovakia, Nominal Price Example, Charlie Hustle Warehouse Sale, Is Cheyenne Woods Related To Tiger Woods, I Will Find A Way Lyrics Hourstone, Thermal Physics Notes Pdf, When Potential Difference Is Applied Across An Electrolyte Then Ohms Law Is Obeyed At, Kevin Carter Boy And Cow, Prodigy Crystal Caverns Map, Wake Up Dead T-pain Mp3, Michigan Humane Society Locations, Middletown Borough, Tell Me If U Still Care Lyrics, Vince Staples Big Time, Cubic Meter Abbreviation, Labor Day Office Games, Evidence-based Interventions Reading, Con Ed Of Ny Intell Ck Ppd Id: 2462467002, Best Wordpress Themes For Lifestyle Blogs, Big Boi Collaboration, Dr Evil 1000 Dollars, Toyoda Sushi, Hair Salons In Plantation, Fl, Best Employee Discount Programs, Nz Weather Outlook, Thank You Sports Team Manager Messages, Ferne Mccann This Morning, Arf Rescue Cats, Lil Yachty - Get Dripped, Black Hills Road Map, What Determines Amperage, Russia Military Armenia, Alek Misev First State Super, Kotter And Schlesinger Resistance To Change Pdf, Vox Pathfinder 10 Cover, Arrowtown Accommodation, Human Trafficking Documentary, Furlough In Spanish Language, Mimi Dancing Dolls Plastic Surgery, Evidence-based Practice In Social Work Pdf, Cornucopia Bar & Burgers Eugene Or, Kirsten Kutner Wikipedia, Adidas Tracksuit Womens Xl, Operation Kenova, Chris Brown Mom Birthday, Poems About Acorns And Oak Trees,